S Corp vs LLC Calculator
When to Elect S Corp

An S corporation (S corp) is a tax status under Subchapter S of the IRS tax code that you can elect for your limited liability company (LLC) or corporation.
S corp status also allows business owners to be treated as employees of the business for tax purposes, which can result in tax savings.
Our S Corp vs. LLC Calculator guide will explain how to tell whether an S corp election is right for your company.
Recommended: For personalized support, contact our trusted partners for a free tax consultation.

Need Help Filing Taxes for Your S Corp?

Find out how much you could be saving by scheduling a consultation with a business accountant.


S Corp vs LLC Tax Savings Calculator

Electing S corp status allows LLC owners to be taxed as employees of the business. This allows owners to pay less in self-employment taxes and contribute pre-tax dollars to 401k and health insurance premiums.

Our calculator will estimate whether electing S corp will result in a tax win for your business. Before using the calculator, you will need to:

  • Determine a reasonable salary for the work you do by comparing similar salaries on websites like Glassdoor or the US Bureau of Labor Statistics.
  • Estimate your net profit for the tax year. Use a conservative estimate that you are likely to meet every year.

S Corp Savings Calculator

Calculate how much you can save by choosing an S Corp tax classification

When to Elect S Corp Status for an LLC

The following criteria determine whether electing the S corp tax classification makes sense for an LLC:

  • The business must meet IRS S corp requirements
  • The business owner(s) must consistently earn a "reasonable salary"
  • The business owner should be able to pay themselves at least $10,000 in distributions
  • The financial tax advantage must offset the cost of maintaining the S corp

IRS S Corp Restrictions

To elect S corp status, a business must have 100 shareholders or less. In addition, S corps may only issue one class of stock. Other S corp requirements include:

  • The business owners must be US citizens or permanent resident aliens
  • Owners must be private individuals and not business entities such as LLCs, corporations, or trusts.

Reasonable Salary

If an LLC elects S corp, the LLC’s owners become employees of the company. Under IRS rules, owner-employees must be paid a reasonable salary – that is, a salary that someone doing the same job would normally earn. The IRS looks to make sure that the S corp is paying its owners reasonable salaries. If a company fails to do so, it may be denied S corp status, have to pay a fine, and/or be required to pay back taxes.

To determine a reasonable salary for your position, you can compare similar salaries on websites like Glassdoor or the US Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Profit and Distribution

After electing S corp status, an LLC owner uses profits to pay salaries and distributions to owner-employees. The business must be able to cover a reasonable salary and at least $10,000 in distributions for the S corp election to make financial sense.

If an LLC owner forfeits a salary, he or she could be fined by the IRS.

Positive Return on Investment

Although the IRS charges minimal filing fees to elect S corp status, there are additional bookkeeping and payroll costs that can be expensive. Some LLCs already have employees and payroll costs, in which case this isn’t really a factor in deciding whether to elect S corp.
Because of the added administrative costs, the tax advantages of electing the S corp classification must be substantial enough to more than cover them for the election to make sense. Generally speaking, a reasonable salary plus $10,000 in annual distributions is often enough to save money on your tax return.

For help choosing payroll and accounting services, see our review of the Best Payroll Software for Small Business.

The Truic Flame Logo

Are you looking for the right business structure for your small business? Visit our How to Choose a Business Structure guide.

How to Start an S Corp

You can start an S corp by electing S corp tax status from the IRS on Form 2553 for:

  • An existing LLC or corporation
  • A new LLC or corporation (we don’t recommend starting a corporation and electing S corp status)

For detailed, step-by-step instructions for starting an S corp in your state, choose your state:

The Truic Flame Logo

Recommended: Reduce your workload and learn more about electing S corp. Schedule a consultation with a business accountant.

S Corp Tax Return FAQ

Do S corps pay income tax?

S corps don’t pay a corporate income tax. Instead, owners pay personal income tax on the company’s earnings. For more information, see our S Corp Taxes guide.

Who pays more taxes, LLC or S corp?

This depends on how much the company makes. As a general rule of thumb, it only makes sense to file taxes as an S corp if there is enough net profit to pay owners a reasonable salary and at least $10,000 in annual distributions.

Check out our LLC Tax Guide, and read more about the similarities and differences between LLCs and S Corps in our LLC vs S Corp guide.

What is the S corp tax rate?

The S corp doesn’t have a specific tax rate because S corp income passes through to the owner’s individual tax return. At that point, the S corp income is subject to federal, state, and FICA taxes based on the individual owner’s tax bracket and filing status.

For more information, see our S Corp Taxes guide.

Does an S corp have limited liability protection?

An S corp is a tax status that can be elected by an LLC or corporation. LLCs and corporations have limited liability protection. A business owner will not lose liability protection by electing S corp tax status.

For more information, see our What is an S Corporation?

Where can I find S corp tax return forms?

You can find the PDF IRS tax returns forms in our S Corp Tax Returns guide.

Is subchapter S the same thing as an S corp?

Yes, subchapter S is the same thing as an S corp. For more information, see our What is an S Corporation guide.

How an S Corp is taxed?

An S corp is a pass-through tax status. The S corp isn’t taxed on its profit. Instead, the profit passes through to the owner's individual tax returns. An S corp does have to pay employer FICA taxes on employee salaries. For more information, see our S Corp Taxes guide.

Does an S corp have to file taxes?

Yes, an S corp files taxes at the state and federal level. For more information, see our S Corp Taxes guide.

Which is better for taxes, an LLC or an S corp?

The default LLC tax status is better for small businesses that reinvest profit to grow their business. An S corp is better for businesses that have profit left over to pay owners a reasonable salary and at least $10,000 in distributions.

For more information, see our LLC vs. S Corp guide.

Do S corps pay state income tax?

Yes, S corp income passes through to the owner’s individual tax returns and is subject to state income taxes.

For more information, see our S Corp Taxes guide.

Does an S corp owner have to take a salary?

Yes, an S corp owner must take a reasonable salary per IRS guidelines. Reasonable is defined as being a fair market salary for the work performed.

For more information, see our What is an S Corporation guide.

Related Articles

Article Sources